Customer Reviews

Overall rating: 5 / 5 from 52 reviews.

Customer photo review of Stella | 4 | Painted Midnight

I wore the Midnight Stellas with a custom blue charm necklace to my sister’s wedding in Cabo San Lucas. I love the look and feel of the charms at Clay Collective, and knew I wanted to build something unique, earthy, and ocean-inspired. The blue ombré look of the Midnight Stellas was exactly what I was after 💙🩵🤍 Thank you, Shay & Molly, for helping me turn an idea into special accessories that I’ll wear again and again.

Stella | 4 | Painted Midnight

Customer photo review of Dotties | Pendant

I own several different earrings by Shay and I love them all!

Dotties | Pendant

Customer photo review of Low Tide Rosary | La Playa

Beautiful, quality wearable artwork. Thank you Shay & team for sharing such timeless pieces with the world. This necklace will accompany me on all my mountain meanderings✨

Low Tide Rosary | La Playa

Customer photo review of Lucky Clover | Pendant

I love using your charms to make my own original jewelry!

Lucky Clover | Pendant

Customer photo review of Shooting Star | Goodnight Moon Collection

The stars are so simple yet so fun! Wore them leading a yoga class, mountain biking, paddle boarding and swimming in a lake- all in one day! Adventure-proof to the max!

Shooting Star | Goodnight Moon Collection

Customer photo review of Scout | Speckle & Leaf

I bought these for my partner’s mom for Christmas. The first time she wore them she sent me this picture and told me about how all her friends needed to know where they were from! I have multiple pairs of earrings for myself, so of course they’re my favorite to gift as well! ❤️

Scout | Speckle & Leaf

Customer photo review of Sweethearts | Rose Red

I adore Shay and the creative energy she always exudes. It shows in every piece of her work! I have taken classes from her as well as know her personally.

Sweethearts | Rose Red

Customer photo review of Sweetheart Dangles |Torn

Cute cute! This is my 4th (?) I think pair of Clay by Shay earrings, and once again, perfect! ❤️ I got this set to wear to Galentine’s day event and have worn them almost daily since! Thanks Shay!

Sweetheart Dangles |Torn

Customer photo review of Stella | 6 | Chartreuse

Have loved my Clay by Shays from the moment my sister gifted me my first pair! They've been my go to for kayaking style, backcountry trips, and family get-togethers. My 3 year old niece pretends to eat them off my ears like sweet tarts every time she sees me in them (she's the lil blondie in the photo)! I get compliments all the time, and tell most everyone to grab themselves a pair :) Thank you for making such an elegant fun unique amazing product with love for all

Stella | 6 | Chartreuse

Customer photo review of Flowers | Charms Only

I love that there is an option to purchase the charms on their own. I have stretched ears, so I normally use kidney wire so that I may wear them through my tunnels. I love these pieces, they're so beautiful.

Flowers | Charms Only

Customer photo review of Stella | 4 | Payette Blues

I found Shay through Instagram I believe but since then I get compliments on these all over the country. They've already traveled all through Europe with me.

Stella | 4 | Payette Blues

Customer photo review of Stella | 6 | Rainbow

I absolutely love these earrings! I love everything Shay puts out there. I have been adventuring in these earrings for over 3 years. Beach, river rafting, canyoneering, skiing, mountain biking, these earrings come everywhere with me! Keep creating magic Shay. I've already got 3 other girls hooked on these.

Stella | 6 | Rainbow

Customer photo review of Tori | Terra

I couldn’t be happier with my custom necklace Shay made for me! It perfectly fits my vibe and is so me, adding the perfect touch to every outfit. Shay’s attention to detail is incredible, and the quality is top notch. She made this necklace for me right before I left to Central America and it’s been on every adventure with me from surfing to swimming in waterfalls! If you’re looking for jewelry that feels personal and unique, I can’t recommend Clay by Shay enough!!

Tori | Terra

Customer photo review of Stella | 6 | Rainbow

I discovered Clay by Shay on a visit to Boise, ID and as a creative entrepreneur with a small business of my own, I was immediately in love with this collective and have been following ever since. I have a hearing impairment that was caused by an injury a couple years ago. Each year on the anniversary, I do something special for my ears, like adorn them with a new pair of earrings. This year I went with Clay by Shay and I get so many compliments on them! I look forward to every opportunity to expand my collection of pieces from Clay by Shay. From my very first visit all those years ago to the purchases I’ve made more recently, I have found that the design, function and aesthetic of Clay by Shay pieces remain timeless. I love supporting this sustainable small business.

Stella | 6 | Rainbow

Customer photo review of Violet + Lemon Drop

ClaybyShay is truly one of a kind. Every piece is so beautifully designed. Her years of experience really shine through in the quality and detail. Her jewelry is lightweight, durable, and perfect for any adventure. What I love most is how personal and thoughtful her designs feel. Shay has an incredible talent for turning clay into wearable art, and her work is unlike anything else out there

Violet + Lemon Drop

Customer photo review of Low Tide Rosary | Hollow

This thing is a piece of me. Beautiful and really durable. I can wear it while surfing without worrying about it breaking or getting damaged. It’s become a favorite accessory that holds up well during all my life’s adventures and activities

Low Tide Rosary | Hollow

I have always loved Clay by Shay’s earrings but I was blown away by the customer service! I had to re-route the earrings to a different state and Shay was just amazing and so personable! I get so many compliments on every pair of earrings I’ve purchased and these ones are a hit! I’m obsessed and love that I can stand behind such an awesome little brand that cares!

Hoops+Rectangles | Sage

I love all the items I’ve purchased by Clay by Shay! Such cool unique pieces

Sage

Quality is great, super fun chic, highly recommend!

Stella | 6 | Moss

These are my favorite go-to earrings, and I have a lot of jewelry. I love the length, the weight, and the light color with my dark hair. They are the perfect earrings!

Stella | 6 | Bone

I’m so excited to give these to my sister for Christmas. They are adorable!

Lucky Dice | Good Luck Charm

My daughter bought me a pair of moon earrings for my birthday. I love them, so much that I decided to buy earrings for my girlfriends and family for Christmas. I am so excited! Thank you.

Rectangles | Lavender

Got this piece for my gf and I’s anniversary. She absolutely loves it! Quality piece with an even cooler back story!

Glacier

I have always been a fan of the earrings but this was my first necklace purchase. The necklace is surprisingly light and dainty - perfect to wear all the time!

Low Tide Rosary | La Playa

I found Shay at Renegade Seattle a couple years ago and love the bowl I bought from her then. I've been slowly getting more pieces to complete a set and love mix-n-matching the colors.

Salad Plates

Love the quality and the look

Classic Charms

These were a present for my mom and she absolutely loves them! Every time she wears them she gets so many compliments.

Stella | 4 | Painted Blues

Friend brought me to this shop when I visited her in ID, fell in love with the artists and their mission, love the way I feel when I wear a pair of earrings. I’ve gifted several pairs to different women in my life as celebrations of their achievements.

Sweetheart Dangles | Rose Red

I bought them for my wife for Valentine’s Day. She loves them and has been wearing them a lot since. Thanks to everyone (especially Molly) for helping me get them in time.

Those Three Words

Love supporting a women owned and operated small business. Shay is such a kind and creative soul and sells amazing clay jewelry!

Scouts | Prickly Pear